Comments on: Coldplay Settles Joe Satriani Lawsuit

By: boom boom pow

boom boom pow — Wed, 04 Nov 2009 04:37:06 +0000

Both band are in equal merit, but this seems a little bit biased. There is logical fact behind it, with 3.2 BILLION people in the world, lots of ideas repeat and coincide. So whats the big deal about these two songs? well, listen through your music library and single out the songs that sound the same…chances are that your not going to find many.

By: boom boom pow

boom boom pow — Tue, 03 Nov 2009 20:37:06 +0000

By: neenaP

neenaP — Sun, 11 Oct 2009 07:01:05 +0000

The person who wrote this is an idiot! The songs are so identical, you really have to be retarded not to hear it.Coldplay never heard of Satriani? Sure. They obviously did since they stole his music.

By: Name

Name — Thu, 08 Oct 2009 20:59:59 +0000

Mate…WTF…..”Meanwhile Joe “First-Place-Winner-in-The-Make-A-Wish-Foundation-Cancer-Kid-Look-Alike-Contest” Satriani is a guitarist, not a song-writer”

First of all kids going through cancer is tragic enough….idio@…

Second if satch wasnt as good as a song writer as a guitarist… why do Cold Play have his melody imbedded in there track?

By: Name

Name — Thu, 08 Oct 2009 20:59:57 +0000

Mate…WTF…..”Meanwhile Joe “First-Place-Winner-in-The-Make-A-Wish-Foundation-Cancer-Kid-Look-Alike-Contest” Satriani is a guitarist, not a song-writer”

First of all kids going through cancer is tragic enough….idio@…

Second if satch wasnt as good as a song writer as a guitarist… why do Cold Play have his melody imbedded in there track?

By: Name

Name — Thu, 08 Oct 2009 20:38:51 +0000

Guys as far as who wrote the melody first… it was clearly Satch…It was also released before Cold Pay..

As far as are there other artists that had a melody simular to satch's before him… Yes…But are they the same melody as satch's… No…. (Not note for note)

Is the cold play melody the same as satch's (I mean note for note, tempo, key…leave nothing to the imagination)…. Yes….

By: Name

Name — Thu, 08 Oct 2009 20:30:44 +0000

I couldnt believe what I was reading in the article above… Everyone writes in the same keys…. Hmmm… No they dont…. Music Theory is available to everyone who wants it….But the fact is most musicians dont know allot about the nuts and bolts….Only a basic understanding, such as Major, Minor, Blues… as mentioned above….

And as for who Joe Satriani is….. Well he is the guitarist that all other guitarist say is the best in the world…He is known for his tone, mastery of the instrument, knowledge of music theory and the use of this theory in composition…

Simply put there is no equal…. And this is acknowledged by his piers…But lets face it he has no interest in writing top 40 pop tunes…And thats one of the things I love about the guy… He writes from the heart…If you like it thats cool… If u dont thats ok to…..

If Cold Play did listen to his tunes and it did spill out as a Cold Play track before they realised… Well theres no Harm in contacting the guy and saying something like… “Sorry champ didnt realise, but will look after you for the use of your tune…”

But that wasnt the case….Was it….

By: loverofjoesat

loverofjoesat — Sat, 03 Oct 2009 03:50:29 +0000

to get to know who joe satriani is, listen to his music. he is his music. if it so happened you doin't like his music, then you don't deserve to hear his music either.

By: Proof that All Artist Are Copy Cats

Proof that All Artist Are Copy Cats — Fri, 02 Oct 2009 17:17:30 +0000

[...] still not convinced. The lawsuit story was a hot article here on Rev with a lot of discussion. One reader pointed out that there is another [...]

By: yourmotherjzkfbhkzxjbfvhkx

yourmotherjzkfbhkzxjbfvhkx — Sun, 27 Sep 2009 04:22:14 +0000

Coldplay is amazing. And This Satriani guy really sucks ass. end of point.