Post Pic

What Is And Isn’t Emo!

 

Alright people listen up! The term emo has been spit on, pooped on, dressed up to look like a poodle, and dragged through psychiatric hospitals thanks to this new generation of teen angst but unfortunately they’ve got it all wrong.

Not very long ago I realized that most of today’s youth considers the music genre ‘emo’ to be something completely different then what it was when I was all over the punk battlefield (the good old days as I refer to them) and I think It’s time we set the record straight.


I’m pretty sure this is a dude.

The image on the left is what the average ‘emo’ kid looked like years ago. A button up short sleeve shirt, a pair of Vans, and the Long Island gel head. The image on the right is what most people today consider to be an emo kid. Emo was a genre of music and that’s it. As you can see in the pic, there was no fashion trends and it wasn’t used to describe a type of troubled youth. It was just mid-tempo punk music.



So how did we get here? The chart below sums it up best.




Emo was basically pop-punk slowed down with some post-hardcore influence and that’s it! It wasn’t dark music, had nothing to do with cutting yourself, and had zero fashion sense. I think it’s time this new generation of emo gets it’s own genre name. What about Nu-Glam? or Golamyth?

In a recent Rolling Stone interview James Suptic, one of the founding members of the Get Up Kids apologizes for the current state of emo. “Honestly, I don’t often think about the state of ‘emo’. The punk scene we came out of and the punk scene now are completely different. It’s like glam rock now,” Suptic told DiS. “We played the Bamboozle fests this year and we felt really out of place. I could name maybe three bands we played with. It was just a sea of neon shirts to us. If this is the world we helped create, then I apologize.” According to Andy Greenwald (senior contributing writer at Spin Magazine), “This was the period (mid-nineties) when emo earned many, if not all, of the stereotypes that have lasted to this day: boy-driven, glasses-wearing, overly sensitive, overly brainy, chiming-guitar-driven college music.” Andy’s description is pretty dead on, at least I thought it was until my recent revelation.

Look, kids will follow the trends, try and push it farther then the guy before to get noticed, then look back years later and try and cover up the evidence. I’m perfectly okay with that. I don’t care about the goth look or if it has become impossible to tell the boys from the girls. It was a very similar environment when I grew up with the Poisons and Wingers. Just don’t call what you’re doing fucking emo or punk. When your main motivation to become a band is to be a rockstar or you go to the shows to ‘be seen’ rather then listen to the music, then you have nothing to do with what ‘emo’ was originally about.

Finally, lets close with some emo music. While it was hard to tell the difference from an indie, punk, or emo band (and I know a lot of bands hated being tagged emo even back then), here are some selections that I considered emo and think you should give a listen.

  • Rites of Spring
    Get-Up Kids were the LAST emo band not the first. They were definitely what went wrong with emo. so they are to blame.
  • der_funkencaptain
    There is no scene on major labels. AT ALL. EVAR. Scenes get ripped apart by majors. The labels end them. Or for the generation you are talking to it's like when Fox bought My Space.
  • Elle
    Drew, I completely agree with what you're saying. Well said :)

    I liked the article though, it was quite interesting and also very true..but I'd think more about some of the connections to how it became what it is today. I mean, I do agree with Hot Topic 100%, but I'm not completely sold on the other ones.
  • drew, if you listen to some of mcr's older stuff (before they were signed to reprise records) you'll find more resemblance... heres an example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gjp4YHAUGjw
  • Also, Tokio Hotel (the boy-girl above with anime hair) has absolutely no relevance to this article.
    They are pure, mainstream, pop.
    That the lead singer looks like that is incidental and unfortunate.
  • The connection you're making between The Get Ups Kids (or any 'emo' band from that time, Promise Ring, Capn Jazz, Rites of Spring, etc) is tenuous at best.

    Firstly, my Chemical Romance has almost no stylistic similarities to any of those bands beyond that they play 'rock'. MCR draws more similarities or inspiration from The Smashing Pumpkins, Queen, glam rock, opera, etc.
    Regardless of anyone's opinion how well or badly they are mimicking those bands or styles, their connection to 'emo' is non-existant.

    The bridge between 'emo' and 'false-emo' is a three-parter.
    It's dissolution of the mis-labeled subculture into mainstream culture, quantified and resold by record industry suits, bridged by the fact that 'the underground' has been completely expoed by the internet.
    Package that all up into a Hot Topic emo survival kit, mix in some non-emo related fashion attachments, and resell it back to the kids who popularized it in the first place.

    It's the same thing that happened in the 90's with pop punk rock. Repackaged as mallpunk made in China and sold back to a similar generation of kids who weren't actually born when Punk broke.
    (if punk was never a 'real' genre)
  • tomr01
    Thanks for memory lane trip. What I don't understand is how the influence of Ink & Dagger and their whole vampire thing bled into what's now "emo." I&D had little to do with emo, except Don Devore from screamo band Frail, but that's a stretch.
  • slbear
    Goth are pussies aren't they? Needing someone to feel sorry for them, for growing up in upper-middle class families and all. Constantly having the need for attention. (People who look bizarre get stared at) that just feeds into the need someone should feet sorry for me. I'm not a freak. I just want attention.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Learn More About Advertising Here
           
Let The News Come To You / Pick One Or All

Enter your email address: